From “Slipping Through My Fingers” to “Dancing Queen,” the bittersweet melodies and energetic hits of classic ABBA songs rang through the amphitheater as the upper school performed “Mamma Mia!.”
The musical follows Sophie, a young bride who dreams of her father walking her down the aisle. But there’s one problem: She doesn’t know who her dad is. While her mother, Donna, hurriedly prepares for the wedding, Sophie secretly invites three men from Donna’s past, believing one of them to be her father.
Auditions for the show were held Thursday, Aug. 29, and the cast list was announced two days later. Rehearsals then began, culminating in four performances from Thursday, Nov. 14 to Saturday, Nov. 16.
Senior Grace Whitney was the show’s assistant director, and she worked alongside director Samara Kelly, stage manager Rachel Chung (‘25), musical director Jan Roper and choreographer Ashley Fisher. “Mamma Mia!” was Whitney’s third show serving as assistant director. She said putting the production together began with identifying the fundamental aspects of each scene and developing the story as it progressed.
“It’s skeletal. First, you bring out what is going to be the initial blocking or character motivation in a very basic sense, and then you get into the finer details the further along you go,” Whitney said. “So it’s not so much building up a scene, making it its final version and then moving on, it’s the basic version, the basic version, the basic version, then we’re going to go back and start again and get more into the final details.”
With “Mamma Mia!” being a well-known production, Whitney said she was initially intimidated. However, she said their show became more unique as the story progressed.
“Are we just going to be mimicking it? That’s always my fear. But then the fun part becomes, ‘How do we make this our own?’ and that’s when it becomes your production,” Whitney said. “It’s no longer that you’re mimicking something. It’s about, ‘How are you making this your own?'”
The show was junior Stella Leland’s second time participating in an Archer musical. They played Eddie, one of the hotel workers on the fictional island, Kalokairi, where the story takes place. Leland said the show improved every rehearsal as the actors began to understand the characters and their motives.
“I was having a lot of fun during the whole process, but especially seeing it all come together. Everyone finding their place and having their role come to life is really nice,” Leland said. “As the show went on people started learning lines and all that stuff, then as everyone grew into their characters, it helped everyone else as well.”
Senior Hayden Seid played Rosie, one of Donna’s best friends. She said the community formed within the cast and crew was one of the musical’s most special aspects.
“Every rehearsal just felt like coming home to a family,” Seid said. “Everyone always cheers for each other and hypes one another up. There’s never an instance where I feel scared to be in front of these people, because literally everyone is so welcoming and selflessly supportive.”
Leland echoed Seid’s love of the theater community. They said the popularity of “Mamma Mia!” increased interest among people who typically don’t get involved with performing arts.
“There was this sense of community that came with it being “Mamma Mia!” because it’s such a well-known and well-loved show that people who usually wouldn’t do theater tried it out,” Leland said. “It’s lovely to see how people who are less comfortable with doing all the dancing and singing become more comfortable over time. And I know a lot of people who started this year plan to do it next year, which is really great.”
For Seid and Whitney, “Mamma Mia!” will be the last musical they are involved in at Archer. Whitney said it was the seniors’ dream production because of the story’s core values of joy, sisterhood and growth.
“We all wanted this to be our senior show. It was the one we all campaigned for so we were really excited. And I think that it being a show so largely centered around female joy is a really nice thing,” Whitney said. “To have a show so perfectly encapsulating sisterhood and women loving and supporting each other, it was really lovely. And also this idea of Sophie going off and starting her adult life, that’s something that really, really, really resonated with a lot of the seniors.”
Seid said performing in “Mamma Mia!” was a dream come true. She said she can’t back to photos and videos from the show without remembering all of the fun she had with her castmates.
“It was so perfect for our last musical to be ABBA. It was just fun from beginning to end because we all know and love the songs. It just felt like one big dance party,” Seid said. “Who wouldn’t want to spend two hours in Greece every day after school?”