Op-Ed: What do you mean you ‘don’t like Taylor Swift’?
March 18, 2021
Seventeen years in the music industry. Nine studio albums. Ten Grammy’s. Thirty-two American Music Awards. Billboard’s Woman of the Decade. American Music Award’s Artist of the Decade, and you’re telling me Taylor Swift is overrated?
This is not meant to persuade the world to become die-hard Swift fans, but rather to re-evaluate how we view one of the music industry’s most famous and successful (female) artists. Like many others, my awareness of Swift grew as her career did, regularly played on the radio with upbeat “Shake it Off” and the catchy “We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together,” and her statement awards show performances and runway outfits always caught my eye. But as her music career took off, so did the public’s hate of the young, blonde, smiling country-pop star.
In the eyes of the public from age 15, Swift was criticized for her many boyfriends, her body and every ounce of her personal life the media was able to glean. The public began to recognize her as the female equivalent of a player, considered disdainful when it’s a woman, and as her pop songs are primarily about love, the judgments of her as a person bled into criticism of her as an artist.
Then the #TaylorSwiftIsOverParty blossomed.
To say I didn’t hop on the bandwagon of thinking Swift was indeed a crazy, manipulative serial-dater would be a lie. Of course, I believed People Magazine, Twitter and the masses: it was cool and trendy to hate on Swift. Her career seemed to be over — the public, (with a helping hand from the media), had finally toppled one of the most successful women in the music industry.
Swift entirely disappeared from the public eye for two years.
Then, in 2017, Swift released her fifteen-track album “Reputation,” and everything changed. She masterfully took every truth, lie and twisted story that had swirled around her reputation (no pun intended), and created a no-skip album to accompany her most powerful era yet.
Swift has since reinvented herself twice more, releasing a documentary and three albums in three years, and is now going on to re-record five studio albums which she now has the full rights to. I have since become a devoted “Swiftie,” and yet I’m constantly hearing the decade-old comments of “Taylor Swift is so basic,” “She’s boy obsessed” and “Her music sucks” that seem to encapsulate all the issues the public still has with her.
Let’s deconstruct these: “Taylor Swift is so basic.” Being “basic” is the newest way for men, really boys, to bring down women and girls’ interests. There is absolutely nothing wrong with liking music, fashion, art or anything that is trendy… it’s trendy for a reason, people like it. Boys use this phrase to insult, and make girls feel inferior; girls, unfortunately, internalize this misogyny and tell themselves “Taylor Swift is so basic” so I can’t like her, and any girl who does isn’t cool.
“She’s boy obsessed.” Swift has dated 12 men. Drake has dated 14 women. Now, who is the media always posing as the serial-dater? Furthermore, why is there anything wrong with a woman dating multiple people? This criticism of Swift has been spouted by every celebrity magazine, talk show host and teenager trying to seem “cool.”
As a result, every girl begins to understand that it’s not acceptable in society to ‘date around’ or to be into guys because that’s what determines your worth, that’s what people look at in school, in your career and even in your family. Such double standards are even addressed in Swift’s song “The Man,” where she questions why men can date many and are seen as a “player” or a “ladies man,” and that never infringes on their career credibility as it does with a woman.
Lastly: “Her music sucks.” You may be a punk rock fan and songs about forbidden romance don’t float your boat, and I’m not here to convince you it should. But more often than not, this comment and others like it are used to make young girls’ taste in music seem inferior because it’s sung by a woman. Not only that, but comments like these give people yet another way to tear down a successful female. Swift exists in a male-dominated field and yet she has held her ground and built herself a career that has lasted over a decade — an impressive feat for a male, and doubly impressive for a female. You may not love the upbeat pop that flows through many of Swift’s songs but objectively, an overwhelming number of people do like it; the album sales and music awards speak for themselves.
So no, Swift is not overrated. And before you go making a snide remark about her, know that it certainly won’t be affecting one of the best-selling music artists in the world, but that you’ll be perpetuating the trend of tearing successful women down.
In the words of Swift, “I want to work really hard while society is still tolerating me being successful.” You can be part of the change. We can dismantle the double standard around female success. While you’re at it: go ahead and give her music a try too.
David Grant • Dec 25, 2021 at 7:47 pm
Her music is awful and there is nothing in that is worth remembering. Unlike Joni Mitchell, who she is compared to, she is a great artist and has written more songs that people will be listening to and artists will be reinterpreting for years to come. That can’t be said for Taylor. She maybe a very nice person and very competent in the business end of things but she doesn’t impress me very much. If this makes a hater then so be it.
Paul • Dec 13, 2021 at 8:02 am
I am 45+, a guy, and a rock guitarist for 35 years. No matter all the “froth” and media hype that surrounds her persona, Swift is objectively a superb musician. She has a savant like gift for melody and harmony. Her current double CD re-release of Red is a tour-de-force of song writing (Metacritic rating of 92%) delivered with a mature voice that now sounds fantastic. She can be lyrically strong and superficial in equal measure, but MUSICALLY, she is one of the greatest songwriters of all time. When people like Billy Joel label her the new Paul McCartney, you’d better take note. Having said that, I think it is a bit absurd to claim that criticism of Swift is equal to “tearing women down”. Criticism of her musicianship (usually from people who are not musicians) is asinine, but certain aspects of her personality may be fair game – nobody’s perfect. It does pain me that such a great musician can’t have a more placid relationship with the public, rather than a marmite one. Whether that is partly of her own making or not, or “just because she is a woman”, I’ll leave it to you to decide.
Chris • Nov 18, 2021 at 9:49 am
She reminds me of the third grader that gets picked on at recess and goes home after school to get her older brother to beat up the other third graders.
In her case any time she feels “wronged” she posts it on social media to get her rabid followers to dump on her “oppressor” and then acts shocked when they send death threats.
On top of that her music is about as deep as a puddle after a 30 second rain shower.
Elle torres • Nov 13, 2021 at 1:09 pm
“American Music Award’s Artist of the Decade, and you’re telling me Taylor Swift is overrated?” Yes, I’m Telling you! Not everyone has to like her, Jesus!🙄
Theresa • Nov 14, 2021 at 4:02 pm
Thank you! And the argument of “tearing down women” is tired and over done. I don’t like her voice or her writing, but, that doesn’t mean that I am tearing her down. It does mean that I turn radio station when her music comes down. There are plenty of popular female singers that I don’t like, Taylor Swift is one of them.
LaRock • Nov 2, 2021 at 6:14 am
She sets guys up then dumps them so she can write songs about how bad men are. She sucks.
Jjosh • Jul 14, 2021 at 1:08 pm
She’s your average rich, pretty white girl who makes catchy songs targeted at heartbroken teenage girls and has sex with hot guys until they ditch her for the next chick. If you like her songs and want to buy into her lifestyle, have at it. But real people have real lives and respect people who are good role models, relatable, etc.
Vanessa • Nov 16, 2021 at 5:30 pm
This is incredibly sexist. It’s actually sickening reading this comment. First you sex shame women…there is NOTHING WRONG with having sex with hot men ladies. And BOLD of you to assume that they ditched HER. Also you claim that she is not respectable as she is not a good role model. Please do your research before making such claims. She has use her platform to raise awareness for gay rights, intersectional feminism, body image and eating disorders, and sexual assault.
Lizette G • Mar 18, 2021 at 7:30 pm
As a die-hard Swiftie, I love this! So well-written and so many great & important points, Thea!